Pictures FileSystem - Best Practice Discussion?

[customaware]

I have started using the Store Pictures in the FileSystem functionality rather than the DB and I am very curious where the best place is to store them and also naming conventions for the Pictures from a Best Practice perspective.

As I see it.....I think there is no argument from the outset that it is better to store them in the filesystem rather than the DB purely from the point of avoiding DB bloat. However, the fact that it was supposed to also avoid the the image remnants accumulating in the webapps/AwareIM folder was attractive.

BUT, as I understand it....

Let's call the webapps/AwareIM Folder... "The Wall"
North of The Wall is off limits....a mystery so to speak to the outside world. The is everywhere between C:\ ..... and webapps\AwareIM
South of The Wall is Westeros..... fully explorable for those Brave enough.

Hence, if I save a Picture South of The Wall then it can potentially be Viewed and Download by ANYBODY in the Seven Kingdoms.
For example.... save a photo called MyPhoto.jpg to C:\AwareIM\Tomcat\webapps\AwareIM\Custom\CSS\mybusinessspace\images\MyPhoto.jpg
Now enter the URL in a Browser https://mydomain/AwareIM/CustomCSS/mybu ... yPhoto.jpg and your image will display in the Browser.
So, this is fine for Aware because it no longer needs take a copy of the image from the BD and place it South of The Wall to display it in the Browser. It is immediately available and no image remnants are created.

To my mind this creates a dilemma depending on the sensitivity of you images/pictures/photos.

For example:

Sensitive Images
Passport Images
Personnel Images
License and Permit Images

Non Sensitive Images
All images that are of "things" or "places" rather than people.

So, am I right in saying that ALL Sensitive Images should be saved North of The Wall and ALL Non Sensitive Images can be saved South of The Wall?

If that is correct, then, for Images North of the Wall... you retain the advantage of getting them out of the DB but lose the advantage of zero remnants South of The Wall being created.


IMAGE FILE NAMING CONVENTIONS:

Which brings me to the next point..... FileSystem Paths.

This is applicable for both North and South of the Wall...

I upload and Image to the app...

When first created the RULE is ...

If Employee.PictureFull WAS CHANGED Then
Employee.PicturePath=SystemSettings.PathIMAGESSecure+Employee.ID+FILE_NAME(Employee.PictureFull)+'.'+FILE_EXTENSION(Employee.PictureFull)

This puts the image in the correct location and names it correctly....

For example.....it can be seen in the folder as 1298956me.jpg

and the FilePath = C:\MYDOCUMENTS\MYBS\SECUREIMAGES\1298956me.jpg

BUT, now if I EDIT the Form that has that image on it again.... AND DO NOT CHANGE A THING... JUST CLICK SAVE...

Aware executes the Rule AGAIN (EVEN THOUGH NOTHING WAS CHANGED) and creates another file called

1298956

And the FilePath = C:\MYDOCUMENTS\MYBS\SECUREIMAGES\1298956.

Sorry for this being so long by would be very interested to get some feedback and would love to establish a "FileSystem Images Best Practice" document that can be shared across the entire 7 Kingdoms.

Cheers,
Mark

[himanshu]

Hi Mark,

Did you get the way to solve this?

BUT, now if I EDIT the Form that has that image on it again.... AND DO NOT CHANGE A THING... JUST CLICK SAVE...

Aware executes the Rule AGAIN (EVEN THOUGH NOTHING WAS CHANGED) and creates another file called

1298956

And the FilePath = C:\MYDOCUMENTS\MYBS\SECUREIMAGES\1298956

AwareIM is not able to detect the actual change and it always runs the rule.

[customaware]

Not really Himanshu.

I intend to try the implementation that Robin presented at the Espinho Conference which looks to me like the best all round solution.

[himanshu]

Thanks, Mark for recalling... will look that presentation again.

[ACDC]

I intend to try the implementation that Robin presented at the Espinho Conference which looks to me like the best all round solution.

Would you care to elaborate a bit on the concept please, I would be interested to understand a bit more about alternatives. I use document attributes in the file system extensively, sounds like the picture to file system attribute works differently

[Jaymer]

I just had this happen to me. Noticed that Rule was firing when it shouldn't.

Rule: If Photos.ThePic WAS CHANGED then ....
and even though its NOT being changed, its recalculating.

Thought I read long time ago to check if FILE_SIZE had changed, but that means I'd have to store it and have not needed to until this point.

[himanshu]

I just had this happen to me. Noticed that Rule was firing when it shouldn't.

Rule: If Photos.ThePic WAS CHANGED then ....
and even though its NOT being changed, its recalculating.

I confirmed with the above statement.

I had spent a lot of time just fix the issue on certain use case ... when you have to make sure you do not create multiple copies of files when they change...or not even changed.